No one, not even I could have seen this, and for once it’s a good thing. No one saw the Yankees playing this well, let alone entering the All-Star break on top of the AL East with a 3 ½ game lead. True, the AL East is playing more like the AL Least nowadays but as a team you just have to play the games on your schedule and see what shakes out. And while the rest of the teams in the division currently seem to have their flaws all exposed at once, the Yankees seem be hitting their stride thanks to health, depth and a little bit of luck.
Starting pitching, C+: Doing just enough to get the job done should probably be the slogan of the Yankees’ pitching staff. There have been flashes of brilliance, mostly provided by Masahiro Tanaka and Michael Pineda, but overall Yankee pitching ranks 11th in ERA in the AL helped generously by the stellar bullpen. The Yankees need consistency from this staff, as well as length to keep their bullpen occasionally rested. Nathan Eovaldi has been the beneficiary of ample run support, which explains his 9-2 record with a 4.50 ERA. Ivan Nova has been solid since returning from TJ surgery and may want to try wearing Eovaldi’s #30 next time he takes the mound in hopes of sharing in the run support. And C.C. Sabathia continues to be the anchor weighing down the ship, and no, that’s not a crack about his weight. Sabathia will continue to be run out there every fifth game if for no other reason than he’s too expensive for the mop-up duty he’s more suited for. But Tanaka and Pineda should have just enough at top of this rotation to keep the ship right.
Offense, A-: The most pleasant surprise of the season has been the abundance of offense. It does come in bunches at time interrupted by the occasional drought, but the Yankees are currently 2nd in all of baseball in runs scored mostly thankful to being 2nd in all of baseball in HRs. The Bronx Bombers are living up to their moniker again. Recently honored (and long overdue) All Star Brett Gardner continues to be the sparkplug for this lineup whether he’s hitting 2nd behind Jacoby Ellsbury or batting leadoff in his absence. The healthy return of Jacoby Ellsbury bodes well for the 2nd half and gives the Yankees the best 1-2 punch in the game. Speaking of healthy, Mark Teixeira’s gluten free diet hasn’t prohibited him from feasting on American League pitching. Tex leads the team in HRs (22) and RBIs (62) and is back to his 2009 form. Brian McCann just missed an All Star selection by seguing last year’s resurgent 2nd half into this year’s 1st half. He also seems to find himself coming up with the biggest hits in the 7th inning and later. And I guess it’s about time I throw some praise to A-Roid. His long storied history of jackassery is hard to overlook. But even harder to overlook has been his All Star worthy 1st half. He’s accepted his DH assignment and providing the most offense at that position since the days of another Yankee comeback story, Daryl Strawberry.
Defense, D+: What was supposed to be a non-issue has been the biggest thorn in the Yankees’ side. The Yankees are 12th in the AL in fielding best represented by Chase Headley, who leads all 3B with 16 errors. All is not lost, especially with Mark Teixeira playing his usual Gold Glove 1B, and who is the reason Headley has 16 errors and not 26. The first two months were not kind to Didi Gregorius either. But he has been a work in progress. Didi is still showing better range and a stronger arm than a certain Pinstripe God. Despite 9 errors, Gregorius is currently tied for 3rd among AL shortstops in defensive WAR. And Brian McCann is keeping the basepaths in check, throwing out 40% of potential basestealers.
Bullpen, A: The offense has been plentiful but the number one reason the Yankees have persevered to first place in the division has been the bullpen. At times overworked and at times overmatched, they seem to be falling into place at the season’s mid-mark. Justin Wilson, Chasen Shreve and Bryan Mitchell give Joe Girardi plenty of set-up options since they are all equally effective against righties and lefties. The return of Adam Warren from the starting rotation gives the Yanks another right-handed option, as well as a reliable spot starter. And despite the occasional hiccup, Dellin Betances and Andrew Miller are the definition of formidable in the back end. They are both striking out hitters at a rate of 14K/9 innings with sub 2.00 ERAs. The Yankees are winning the games they are supposed to win because of this tandem.
Bench, B: The Yankees have been mercilessly stricken by the injury bug over the past few seasons, and thankfully learned their lesson. Chris Young has been a find as their 4th OF, providing 10 HRs in limited duty. Garrett Jones has been useful as a left-handed bat, as well as OF and back-up to Tex at 1B. And John Ryan Murphy may not be replacing Brian McCann anytime soon, but he’s excelled in his back-up duty.
Manager, B+: Joe Girardi continues to be the calm head that keeps this Yankee team focused during their most trying times. He’s also adept, like his predecessor Joe Torre, at handling the media and keeping them at bay when necessary. This is has been most evident with his handling of the return of A-Roid. He’s done a first-rate job of juggling an aging lineup as well as shaking things up, like when he slotted Chase Headley 2nd during Jacoby Ellsbury’s DL stint. The only qualm I would have would be his overuse of the bullpen at times. Perhaps it’s a by-product of the modern day game with more pitching changes than Katy Perry costume changes at the Super Bowl halftime show. I would just like to see Girardi as being a little more old school and having a little more faith in his starters at times to get out of jams themselves. Otherwise, Girardi has proven time and time again to be the right fit for this team.
Outlook: The Yankees are right where they need to be, having won 7 of their last 10 and getting healthy at the right time. There was talk of trading for a starting pitcher or middle infielder but the recent success of Tanaka and Pineda as well as the impressive debut of 2B Rob Refsnyder may put that plan on hold. The Yankees are primed to win the AL East. They aren’t close to being a championship caliber team but they are playing their best ball since 2012 and ready to make some noise in October.